Sunday, Jun 1 2025 | Time 19:25 Hrs(IST)
IndiaPosted at: May 31 2025 12:51AM


SC upholds UPSIDC's land cancellation to Kamala Nehru Memorial Trust

New Delhi, May 30 (UNI) The Supreme Court on Friday upheld the decision of the Uttar Pradesh State Industrial Development Corporation (UPSIDC) to cancel a 125-acre land allotment to the Kamala Nehru Memorial Trust (KNMT), citing payment defaults and systemic flaws in the process of land allocation.
A Bench comprising Justices Surya Kant and N. Kotiswar Singh rejected the Trust's appeal against the 2017 judgment of the Allahabad High Court, which had affirmed the cancellation of the allotment originally made in September 2003 and annulled in December 2006.
While dismissing the appeal, the Apex Court delivered a sharp rebuke to UPSIDC, observing that the land was allotted “within just two months” and “without any proper evaluation of public benefit".
The Court held that such allocation practices violated the Public Trust Doctrine, which mandates that state-held resources be allocated transparently, with due diligence, and solely for the benefit of the public.
“The Doctrine requires that allocation decisions be preceded by a thorough assessment of public benefits, beneficiary credentials, and safeguards ensuring continued compliance with stated purposes,” the Court said.
The Bench criticised UPSIDC for failing to adopt a transparent and competitive process in allocating such a large tract of industrial land. “This betrays the fiduciary relationship between the State and its citizens,” the Court remarked, stressing that state authorities must ensure accountability in managing public assets.
The judgment noted that no verifiable evidence was considered by UPSIDC regarding the economic benefits, employment potential, environmental impact, or alignment with regional development objectives before making the allotment to the Trust. “Such lapses not only deprived the public exchequer of potential revenue due to the appreciated value of the land but also created a system where privileged access supersedes equal opportunity,” the Court observed.
The Supreme Court further flagged concerns over UPSIDC’s eagerness to re-allocate the land to another entity during the pendency of the litigation. “We, therefore, consider it necessary to examine whether UPSIDC's procedure for industrial land allotment meets standards of administrative propriety, particularly in light of the Public Trust Doctrine mandating that public resources be managed with due diligence, fairness, and in conformity with public interest,” the Court said.
In a judgment authored by Justice Surya Kant, the Court laid down binding directions to reform the process of industrial land allotment in Uttar Pradesh.
It directed, “The State Government of Uttar Pradesh and UPSIDC are directed to ensure that any such allotment in the future be made in a transparent, non-discriminatory and fair manner by ensuring that such allotment process fetches maximum revenue and also achieves the larger public interest like industrial development priorities, environmental sustainability, and regional economic objectives.”
Also, the Court asked that the subject land be re-allotted strictly in accordance with the procedure above.
The Court directed UPSIDC for transparent, non-discriminatory Industrial Land Allocation in Uttar Pradesh.
UNI SNG RN
Tags: #SC upholds UPSIDC's land cancellation to Kamala Nehru Memorial Trust
More News
ADB President meets PM Modi, says lender will pump USD10 bn into India for infra projects

ADB President meets PM Modi, says lender will pump USD10 bn into India for infra projects

01 Jun 2025 | 5:55 PM

New Delhi, June 1 (UNI) Asian Development Bank (ADB) President Masato Kanda today met Prime Minister Narendra Modi, during which he described the Viksit Bharat 2047 vision as “bold” and added that the global lender will support the vision by pumping $10 billion over the next five years into infrastructure development in India.

see more..
Air Marshal Jasvir Singh Mann takes over as Sr Air Staff Officer, Western Air Command

Air Marshal Jasvir Singh Mann takes over as Sr Air Staff Officer, Western Air Command

01 Jun 2025 | 12:52 PM

New Delhi, June 1 (UNI) Air Marshal Jasvir Singh Mann took over as Senior Air Staff Officer of Western Air Command, Indian Air Force on Sunday.

see more..
Shailendra Nath Gupta takes charge as Director General Defence Estates

Shailendra Nath Gupta takes charge as Director General Defence Estates

31 May 2025 | 9:21 PM

New Delhi, May 31 (UNI) Shailendra Nath Gupta on Saturday assumed the office of Director General of Defence Estates.

see more..
Kharge demands special Parliament session over CDS remarks made in Singapore

Kharge demands special Parliament session over CDS remarks made in Singapore

31 May 2025 | 9:07 PM

New Delhi, May 31 (UNI) Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge on Saturday called for a special session of Parliament, alleging that recent remarks made by the Chief of Defence Staff (CDS) during an interview in Singapore, raise several important questions.

see more..
Indian Army conducts trials of next-gen defence technologies under simulated operational conditions

Indian Army conducts trials of next-gen defence technologies under simulated operational conditions

31 May 2025 | 8:11 PM

New Delhi, May 31 (UNI) The Indian Army is currently undertaking extensive capacity development demonstrations at key locations across the country, including the Pokhran Field Firing Ranges, Babina Field Firing Ranges, and Joshimath, with dedicated Air Defence equipment demonstrations also scheduled at Agra and Gopalpur.

see more..