States » EastPosted at: Oct 8 2026 12:20PM


Orissa HC cautions against misuse of PILs without supporting evidence

Bhubaneswar, Oct 8 (UNI) The Orissa High Court has warned against the misuse of Public Interest Litigation (PIL) to air unsubstantiated grievances, saying petitions based on mere apprehension and unsupported claims cannot invoke its extraordinary jurisdiction.
A Division Bench comprising Chief Justice Harish Tandon and Justice Chittaranjan Dash made the observation while dismissing as “sans merit” a PIL challenging the proposed continuation of auction of the “Luna River Sand Sairat”, a government-designated sand quarry, at Demando village under Tilakana Gram Panchayat in Cuttack district.
The Bench observed that PIL petitions were increasingly being filed without supporting documents, corroborative evidence, adequate research or expert opinion.
It further maintained merely approaching the court in the name of villagers does not automatically give a petition the character of public interest litigation.
The PIL was filed by two persons claiming to represent villagers, who alleged that sand extraction had damaged the river, embankment and village road and caused hardship to local residents. They also claimed that villagers were unaware of the 2020-21 auction of the sand quarry.
The court, however, found no evidence of river or embankment erosion, or any research or expert opinion establishing that sand extraction had affected the river’s natural flow, damaged its embankment or disturbed the local ecological system.
While acknowledging that environmental protection and preservation of natural resources are matters of public concern, the Bench said the High Court cannot intervene on the basis of mere apprehension or “ipse dixit” — an assertion without supporting proof.
It further held that where the statutory framework entrusts competent authorities with assessing environmental and technical aspects, the High Court should not undertake such an assessment on the basis of unsubstantiated allegations. Judicial intervention would be warranted only if there is material to show that prescribed safeguards were not followed or that the authorities’ decision was illegal.
The Bench dismissed the PIL without imposing costs.
UNI MK ATP ARN
Tags: #Orissa HC cautions against misuse of PILs without supporting evidence
More News

Meghalaya : GSMC condemns GHADC term extension, demands council polls

08 Oct 2026 | 1:41 PM

Tura, Oct 7 (UNI) The Garoland State Movement Committee (GSMC), a prominent socio-political organisation in Meghalaya, has strongly condemned the state government's decision to grant a second six-month extension to the term of the Garo Hills Autonomous District Council (GHADC).

see more..

NGT order unimplemented, Odisha officials put on notice over forest encroachments

08 Oct 2026 | 12:20 PM

Bhubaneswar, Oct 8 (UNI) A year-and-a-half after asking Odisha authorities to clear illegal encroachments from the Reserve Forest and government land in Nayagarh district, the National Green Tribunal (NGT) has issued notices over alleged non-compliance with its directions, including a one-month deadline for action.

see more..

Orissa HC cautions against misuse of PILs without supporting evidence

08 Oct 2026 | 12:20 PM

Bhubaneswar, Oct 8 (UNI) The Orissa High Court has warned against the misuse of Public Interest Litigation (PIL) to air unsubstantiated grievances, saying petitions based on mere apprehension and unsupported claims cannot invoke its extraordinary jurisdiction.

see more..

INDIA bloc bandh affects normal life across Odisha

08 Oct 2026 | 12:18 PM

Bhubaneswar, Oct 8 (UNI) Normal life was affected across Odisha on Thursday as the Congress-led INDIA bloc enforced a 12-hour statewide bandh, affecting road and rail traffic, public transport, educational institutions and commercial activity.

see more..

Bihar CM Samrat Choudhary condoles death of Nana Patekar

08 Oct 2026 | 11:45 AM

Patna, Oct 8 (UNI) Bihar Chief Minister Samrat Choudhary on Thursday expressed deep grief over the demise of renowned actor Nana Patekar, saying Indian cinema had lost a great and versatile artiste with his death at the age of 75.

see more..