IndiaPosted at: Nov 2 2026 6:45PM


Justice P S Narasimha recuses from plea seeking finalisation of MoP for judges’ appointments

Parmod Kumar
New Delhi, Nov 2 (UNI) Supreme Court judge Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha on Monday recused himself from hearing a public interest litigation by NGO Lok Prahari seeking finalisation of the Memorandum of Procedure laying down the process for appointment of judges to the Supreme Court and High Courts.

As the matter came up before a bench comprising Justices Narasimha and Alok Aradhe, Justice Narasimha said he had earlier appeared as Additional Solicitor General in a similar matter concerning the MoP and therefore would not hear the petition.

Besides seeking finalisation of the appointment procedure, the PIL has also sought directions to bring decisions of the Supreme Court Collegium within the ambit of the Right to Information Act.

The petition contends that appointments to the constitutional courts should be based on the unanimous view of the Collegium after taking into account the criteria identified by the Supreme Court in its December 16, 2015 order.

The December 16, 2015 order by a five-judge Constitution Bench said the Central government would finalise the Memorandum of Procedure in consultation with the Chief Justice of India, who, in turn, would act on the unanimous view of the Collegium comprising the four seniormost puisne judges of the Supreme Court.

The order identified several matters to be incorporated into the MoP, including eligibility criteria, transparency in appointments, creation of a secretariat, a mechanism for dealing with complaints and other appropriate measures.

The five-judge Constitution Bench that delivered the October 16, 2015 judgment striking down the NJAC as unconstitutional and subsequently passed the December 16, 2015 order comprised Justices Jagdish Singh Khehar, J Chelameswar, Madan B. Lokur, Kurian Joseph and Adarsh Kumar Goel, all of whom have since retired.

The MoP, which lays down the procedure followed under the Collegium system, was originally framed in 1999. The question of revising it resurfaced after the five-judge Constitution Bench, on October 16, 2015, struck down the National Judicial Appointments Commission(NJAC). Subsequently, by its December 16, 2015 order, the Court left it to the Central government to prepare a revised procedure after considering suggestions for improving transparency in judicial appointments.

The issue of finalising the revised MoP also reached the Supreme Court judicially in 2017. On October 27 that year, a bench of Justices Adarsh Kumar Goel and Uday Umesh Lalit, while dealing with a petition by advocate R P Luthra said there should be no indefinite delay in finalising the MoP.
The bench observed that “there should be no further delay in finalization of MOP in larger public interest” and issued notice to the Attorney General while appointing senior advocate K V Vishwanathan as amicus curiae. K V Viswanathan is now a judge of the Supreme Court.

The matter was subsequently placed before a three-judge bench comprising then Chief Justice Dipak Misra, Justices A K Sikri and Amitava Roy, all of whom have since retired.

On November 8, 2017, the three-judge bench recalled the October 27 order and disposed of Luthra’s petition, holding that there was no necessity to proceed with the remaining prayers in view of the earlier judgments concerning the NJAC and the framing of the MoP.
UNI XC RSA
Tags: #Justice P S Narasimha recuses from plea seeking finalisation of MoP for judges’ appointments
More News

Vijender Gupta inaugurates SAU auditorium, releases Maj Gen Bakshi’s book on Vedic science

02 Nov 2026 | 7:20 PM

New Delhi, Nov 2 (UNI) Emphasising the need to reconnect younger generations with India’s intellectual and civilisational heritage through research and fresh perspectives, Delhi Legislative Assembly Speaker Vijender Gupta on Monday said that the future of the country’s intellectual legacy would depend on the questions young people were willing to ask.

see more..

INS Sudarshini returns to Kochi after 10-month transoceanic voyage, covers over 22,000 nautical miles

02 Nov 2026 | 7:06 PM

New Delhi, Nov 2 (UNI) The Indian Navy's sailing vessel INS Sudarshini returned to Kochi on Monday after completing an extraordinary 10-month transoceanic expedition, covering more than 22,000 nautical miles across the world's oceans and strengthening India's maritime outreach through engagements with 11 countries.

see more..

UNI NEWS DIGEST AT 1900 HRS ON NOV 2

02 Nov 2026 | 7:00 PM

TOP STORIES OF THE DAY.

see more..

Delhi chokes as AQI touches 405 in several areas

02 Nov 2026 | 6:48 PM

New Delhi, Nov 2 (UNI) Delhi continued to grapple with worsening air pollution on Monday, with the Air Quality Index (AQI) climbing to 324 by evening and several parts of the national capital recording readings above 400, even as relatively cool temperatures, shallow morning fog and largely clear skies offered little respite from the choking conditions.

see more..

Justice P S Narasimha recuses from plea seeking finalisation of MoP for judges’ appointments

02 Nov 2026 | 6:45 PM

Parmod Kumar
New Delhi, Nov 2 (UNI) Supreme Court judge Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha on Monday recused himself from hearing a public interest litigation by NGO Lok Prahari seeking finalisation of the Memorandum of Procedure laying down the process for appointment of judges to the Supreme Court and High Courts.

see more..